There are weeks that can determine a club’s season, and there are weeks that can determine a club’s future. It is no exaggeration to suggest the latter awaits Everton. Monday is a must-win Premier League home match against rivals Crystal Palace, the only team to have beaten Everton in their last 11 games.
The release of victory in the FA Cup third round replay proved fleeting as a fourth round exit to Luton followed ten days later. There is no date in the diary, but Everton also expect a ruling this week on their appeal against a 10-point deduction for a single breach of the Premier League’s profit and sustainability rules. The consequences will be significant when it comes to that.
The return of the points that Sean Dyche’s side have already won on the pitch would obviously support their fight against relegation, but thanks to an independent commission that accepts some or all of the club’s arguments, it would also strengthen Everton’s defense against the should strengthen the second PSR complaint. brought last month. However, if you lose the appeal, not only does the 10-point penalty remain in effect, but the threat of a second point deduction before the end of the season increases. After all, the second charge covers two-thirds of the period in which Everton have already been found guilty of a £19.5 million infringement.
A club ranked third from bottom, heavily in debt, whose ownership status is shrouded in uncertainty and currently led by an interim CEO and an interim CFO, would be at high risk of going into its final season organize championship football. Goodison Park. And Palace think they have problems.
Barring a return of 10 points – which seems unlikely given Everton admitted at the hearing in October that they had exceeded the PSR by £9.7 million – the risk of a first relegation in 73 years is real. Everton insisted the appeal was their main focus when they were sued by the Premier League for a second time in January. The call was the opening paragraph of a commercial update last week from chief commercial and communications officer Richard Kenyon, who revealed progress was being made on a naming rights deal for the new stadium at Bramley-Moore Dock.
But a call that has understandably taken up the club’s time cannot distract from the daunting task facing a team that has lost strength, energy and momentum since Christmas. Dyche says he prefers to act in reality rather than maybe. The reality is that Everton desperately need the call in their favor as they are running out of options to save themselves on the pitch as they stand.
Related: Martin Tyler: ‘I put some air in my lungs, shouted Aguero’s name and kept going’
Everton were on a roll before being hit with the biggest sporting sanction in Premier League history in November. Afterwards, Dyche’s challenging unit made it easy to rise from second place to the bottom of the table with four consecutive wins. The fourth in the series came on December 16 at Burnley. Everton had recorded a 2-0 result at half-time when top scorer Abdoulaye Doucouré went off with a hamstring injury. They have not won a league match since.
The ensuing downturn included home and away games with both Manchester City and Tottenham, as well as two morale-damaging cup finals at Goodison against Fulham and Luton. Dyche claims Everton have only seriously underperformed recently in the 3-0 defeat to Wolves. Character and commitment were otherwise fine, but the lack of threat through open play was striking during the arid series.
Everton’s striker is not doing enough to ease the pressure on the team’s often impressive defense. Dominic Calvert-Lewin has not scored in 18 games. Beto’s contributions off the bench have shown why Calvert-Lewin continues to start despite his goal drought.
Doucouré has missed 10 of the past 11 games as the injury worsened during his comeback against Aston Villa. The return of last season’s relegation savior, who has resumed full training, will fuel Everton’s hopes of another breakout provided he remains fit. The influential midfielder was the only notable absentee from the team that impressively defeated Newcastle and Chelsea before Christmas.
Dyche explored several alternatives during Doucouré’s timeout – James Garner, Jack Harrison, André Gomes and Arnaut Danjuma – but with little success. His options outside of a small core of first-team talent are limited, hence the lack of rotation Everton overtook over the festive period. The spark that was ignited by a sanction that the club labeled as ‘completely disproportionate and unjust’ has gone out. It urgently needs to be revived, regardless of the verdict on appeal.
While Everton’s case is the result of years of mismanagement that sparked mass protests by fans against owner Farhad Moshiri and the club’s former board, it has also exposed serious flaws in the Premier League’s regulatory framework. The argument for an independent regulator has been further strengthened. The suspicion among Evertonians that the Premier League has used their club as a convenient scapegoat to show that an independent regulator is not necessary has hardened since the appeal.
The culture, media and sport committee was so unimpressed by Richard Masters’ performance last month that it wrote to the sports minister, Stuart Andrew, asking him to introduce the Football Governance Bill as soon as possible feed. Another request for the Premier League to reveal how it arrived at its own formula for accumulating Everton points in the interests of transparency was rejected by the organisation’s CEO. Masters responded: “As the committee will understand, being a private company it is not our practice to provide or publish minutes of Premier League board meetings. We are also unable to publish submissions from the Premier League board or management as part of confidential legal proceedings.”
Behind one mess lies another, in the form of the protracted takeover of Everton by 777 Partners. It has now been 156 days since the announcement that the controversial US investment company had agreed to acquire Moshiri’s majority stake and the deal is still awaiting Premier League approval.
By comparison, it took 51 days between the deal and the approval of Sir Jim Ratcliffe’s investment in Manchester United. The delay seems understandable in light of 777’s legal challenges in the US and Masters’ comment to the CMS committee that some acquisitions will inevitably take longer than others “if we have not received satisfactory answers to the questions we have asked” . A separate, unanswered question is why Moshiri remains committed to the 777 deal when there is interest elsewhere in his stock holdings.
777 remains optimistic, claiming Premier League approval could come this month. Company officials have attended Everton matches, visited the Finch Farm training ground and the club’s offices in the Liver Buildings despite the deadlock. It is understood that the structure of 777’s deal with Moshiri means it will pay Everton less in the event of relegation from the Premier League. In the meantime, more funding must be secured to complete the construction of the stadium at Bramley-Moore Dock. A defining period indeed.